Quantcast willametteLive.com || My Fair Lady cleans up nicely at Pentacle

willamettelive.com - your source for news in the willamette valley
ADVERTISEMENT

   

Log-in | Signup (Free!)
My Fair Lady cleans up nicely at Pentacle
By Therese ONeill
from WillametteLive, Section Stage
Posted on Tue Sep 01, 2009 at 12:08:53 AM PDT

"She's so deliciously low. So horribly dirty."

Professor Henry Higgins has accepted a new project this month at Pentacle Theatre: taking a braying cockney flower girl and raising her up to the heights of society by means of proper English speech. He means not just to improve her vowel pronunciation, but to sculpt an entirely new woman out of soiled gutter clay. All his troublesome lessons, the ones he teaches and the ones he learns, are put forth for Salem’s entertainment by director Geri Lyne Greeno-Sanders.

Heather Dunkin Schwartz plays Eliza Doolittle. Schwartz is a Pentacle gem, seeming to appear in as many plays as they can fit her in. She has both the singing voice of an opera diva and the ability to loudly express herself without opening her mouth. Her wide-eyed Eliza captures the sympathy and support of the audience from her first unintelligible caterwaul in the opening scene.

Jeff Sanders, another Pentacle favorite, plays Henry Higgins. Sanders is not a professional singer, but he is a fine actor. He's gifted in comedic timing, and has a great deal of fun with the sniping character he performs. His fun is ours; he is quite skilled at infecting an audience with the enjoyment he is experiencing.

The cast also features Art James as Higgin’s comrade, the sweet and stuffy Colonel Pickering, and Tom Wrosch as Eliza’s delightfully amoral father Alfred. Wrosch has the difficult job of portraying the drunkard who sells his daughter for five pounds to a stranger as an endearing cad, instead of a disturbing creep. He succeeds, for the most part, by means of roaring, good-natured bluster.

Tony Zandol’s stage design is a return to what Pentacle does best, minimalist elegance with plenty of open space for the audience's imagination to fill.

If there was anything wrong with Pentacle’s production, it was within their noble intention of providing live music to accompany the actors. Two pianos, played by Jerry Bull and John Livingstone, sit on either side of the stage. I cannot say what the result was for audience members sitting directly in front of the stage, but in the wings, the pianos did not mesh with each other or with the singers. With the exception of the powerful voice of Ms. Schwartz, the music overwhelmed the players. This was especially true, unfortunately, of lead actor Sanders, whose strength of voice did not match his strength of performance.

I have seen the famous film of this play many times, with its immortal stars Harrison and Hepburn. But I must say, until viewing Pentacle’s rendition, I did not realize "My Fair Lady" was a musical comedy. Higgins and Eliza are written as rather abrasive, almost dreadful characters. However, Sanders and Schwartz, both natural comedians, manage to make them entirely loveable and very funny. The theatre sparkled with well deserved laughter throughout the entire three and a half hours.




My Fair Lady (#1)
by Anonymous on Wed Sep 02, 2009 at 03:43:38 PM PDT
With much respect, I have to disagree with some of your review. I saw the show Sunday afternoon and sat over behind the grand piano player on the side. I was able to hear every word that was said or sung, and did not find Mr. Sanders lacking in any strength of voice nor did I find the other performers overwhelmed by the pianos. Rex Harrison was not a professional singer either when he originated the role on Broadway with Julie Andrews playing Eliza. I felt that live music seemed a nice touch for such an elegant performance. Also, the show did not run 3 and a half hours as you indicated. While the show is a traditional musical and those run long, it was over after 3 hours and that included the intermission. Lastly, Ms. Schwartz was lovely as Eliza and in fact an improvement over Hepburn who, did not make the role famous- as I said earlier it was made famous by Julie Andrews on the stage. And how can you compare a musical theatre actress to a film star who didn't even do her own signing and really seems out of place until she shows up proper later in the film. I find it interesting that you failed to mention anything else about the other performers on stage. There are many other performers who failed to be mentioned- all of whom are outstanding in their roles. I enjoyed the woman who played Higgins' mother. She was just such a gem. While I respect the right to the reviewer to have her own opinion, in mine, this was the best musical I have ever seen at Pentacle, and I have been attending shows there regularly for years. I do hope they continue to provide such quality entertainment.

My Fair Lady (#2)
by Anonymous on Thu Sep 03, 2009 at 04:14:16 PM PDT
How could the singers not be heard?!? They were MIKED, for heaven's sake. And Tom had "difficulty" keeping Alfred from being a "creep"??? This is "My Fair Lady", Ms. O'Neill, not "The Day of the Locust". I saw the production Wednesday night. It was clean and fresh, well-paced, and superbly performed by the entire cast.

Best seat in the house (#3)
by Anonymous on Sat Sep 05, 2009 at 10:31:51 AM PDT
I would like to thank the posters of the previous 2 comments--as one of the pianists for this show, I can honestly say I have the best seat in the house! And, contrary to what can be presumed from Ms O'Neill's original review, I can hear every word of every song--that's part of my job :) Based on the inaccuracies in her review, I would encourage the editors of the Salem Weekly to also employ fact-checkers in the future for these reviews...Clearly from most of her review, she was surprised & entertained by the performance, moreso than the movie she writes she has seen "many times." She should have left it at that, rather than feel the need to scramble or create something for which to be critical.


 POST A COMMENT

Your opinion matters! This is your chance to add to the story and voice your opinion. Links are welcome and encouraged.

We also encourage you to register an account and to login prior to posting comments. However, this is not required to post a comment. If you are not logged in, the comment will be posted as "Anonymous."

Subject:

Comment:

Enter the two words below to prove that you are a legitimate user.

 RELATED LINKS
> Also by Therese ONeill
 USER INFO

Login to post comments

Need an Account? Signup

Username:
Password:
 YOUR TURN
Most Comments: The Roxxy Moves Into Lefty's space in Salem

Latest Comment: Face the Fact January 2010

Comments:
> Lamers (Anonymous)
> We're missing the point (Anonymous)
> BEST PLACE TO ENJOY YOURSELF AND FREINDS (Anonymous)
> Just my opinion (Anonymous)
> Roxxy employees (Salem Monthly Editors)
ADVERTISEMENT