ADVERTISEMENT
willametteLive.com advertising
willametteLive.com promotions
willamettelive.com - your source for news in the willamette valley CITY ELECTION FORUM - Search - Classifieds - About / Advertise
Idoltude: Michael Johns eliminated from American Idol
By Katie Moore
from WillametteLive, Section Screen
Posted on Thu Apr 10, 2008 at 10:32:18 PM PDT

Idol Gives Back is a worthy cause. And from the bottom of my heart, I truly hope it reaches its goal. But why, WHY must it be encompassed by Christianity?

Last night's program ended with the Christian song "Shout to the Lord," sung by the Idols with a full-on gospel choir backing them up. Tonight's audience was treated to a similar performance.

Couldn't the producers have chosen a more inclusive song for this year's charity drive? America is full of Jews, Muslims, atheists, Hindus, Buddhists, Catholics, Taoists, Sikhs, not to mention the zillion different tribal religions out there. And guess what? They also might feel moved to donate.

For a program that is crossing borders to help people, perhaps the producers could have been a bit more sensitive to the rest of the world. There are plenty of secular songs out there that have an excellent message that wouldn't have alienated thousands of viewers.

To make matters worse, Carly did not get voted off the show. Instead, we lost Michael Johns, who may not have given a solid performance every night, but was still way more interesting to watch than, say, Kristy Lee Cook.

In fact, Michael was just warming up. His recent performances (aside from his copy-cat version of "Dream On") have been his best. I guess he should have warmed up faster. See ya, Michael. You didn't have a chance of winning anyway.

The rest of the show was an extension of last night's program, with a stream of stars beseeching America to give what they can to charity. So far AI has raised $60 million for six different charities, which is still a far cry (at least by my standards) from last year's $76 million. But, hey, we're in a recession, right? The African children dying of malaria will understand. We need our TiVo!





shout to the lord (#1)
by Anonymous on Thu Apr 10, 2008 at 11:59:35 PM PDT
What is wrong with including a great song in a program devoted to good music? Regardless of religious focus, the song stands and holds up.  The focus of any well-crafted tune should not warrant its exclusion.

Why are you attacking? (#2)
by Anonymous on Fri Apr 11, 2008 at 11:32:26 AM PDT
I am saddened when I read such attacks against Christianity. No one seethes with such anger when the atheistic "Imagine" by John Lenin is sang. Even Christians let that go because everyone is free to share what they like. So why not Christianity? Why all the anger? Hardly helpful to the cause. Consider examining your own heart and just help instead of lashing out ...

Idoltude: Michael Johns eliminated from American I (#3)
by Anonymous on Fri Apr 11, 2008 at 11:34:06 AM PDT
Anyone of the Idols could have been eliminated as they are all talented in their own way. At this stage, it all depends on their choice of song and performance on that day, and how many fans they have.
Why should Carly be voted off the show? She has a fantastic voice and personality. And if Katie thinks that Michael Johns is more interesting to watch than Kristy Lee Cook, that's because Michael is a handsome man. I find Kristy Lee Cook more interesting to watch. She has the look of a star, is so gorgeous, and her singing has improved a lot in the last couple of weeks.

I agree with the last person (#4)
by Anonymous on Fri Apr 11, 2008 at 12:19:36 PM PDT
I find it ironic that Christians assume that by asking that other religions be included in the group songs performed by obviously diverse musicians singing to an obviously diverse audience is "angry."

Christians have a false sense of entitlement. If anything it just makes those people look ridiculous in the world's view. If someone disagrees with you, it doesn't make them angry or hateful towards your beliefs. And had these group songs been solo performances chosen by the singer themselves I doubt there would have been any commentary from anyone about it.

I guarantee you that if "Imagine" had been sang during group performances of inspirational week that all of the Evangelicals would be up in arms. Look at the controversy around The Golden Compass which had nothing to do with atheism at all. Of course, "Imagine" was instead sang by the Mormon David Archuleta so there's no argument cause he's "one of you".

I mean Kristy Lee Cook butchered "God Bless the U.S.A" and I don't think any flags were burned in revolt.


#2 "Lashing Out" (#5)
by Anonymous on Sat Apr 12, 2008 at 02:42:06 PM PDT
Yeah, try telling the people of Iraq and Afghanistan that, buddy. Under the guise of Christianity, this "God-fearing" nation has killed millions of people and then tries to use the same voice to woo donations to help out the people we f@*#ed over. Maybe the writer is sick and tired of hearing about the "good" things Christians do and would like the good things (without strings attached) that other groups of people do acknowledged. Christians are often the most hateful people I know--let's see they hate homosexuality, divorced people, drinkers, smokers, atheists, prostitutes, drug users, liberals, Democrats, and any other group that doesn't fit into their narrow definition of "saved". So maybe lashing out is the appropriate thing to do. Or to stop watching Idol and other shows that give this gratuitous hand job to Christians. But, if the writer did that, there would be no Idoltude and what would you do instead? You'd have to find some other blog with an inclusive attitude to criticize. I'd hate it if you had to work that hard for your beliefs.



ADVERTISEMENT