ADVERTISEMENT
willametteLive.com advertising
willametteLive.com promotions
willamettelive.com - your source for news in the willamette valley CITY ELECTION FORUM - Search - Classifieds - About / Advertise
Idoltude: American Idol's creepy Carly Smithson goes home; bumbling Brooke stays another week
By Katie Moore
from WillametteLive, Section Screen
Posted on Wed Apr 23, 2008 at 10:49:12 PM PDT

The American Idol results are in. Many thought for sure that Brooke White would be the one to sing adieu after last night's flub. Fortunately for Brooke, she was scooped up as VoteForTheWorst.com's pick, giving her enough votes to stick around another week and entertain us yet again with her shaky, Chihuahua-like demeanor. Jason Castro was also given a pass, probably for his dreamy eyes and insanely adorable personality. We're perfectly content for him to stick around the rest of the season.

Instead, Carly Smithson and Syesha Mercado were the Bottom Two. Both of whom gave surprisingly decent performances, considering how bland they have both been over the past few weeks. Sorry, girls. Too little too late. Carly, who resembles a vampire with her strangely shaped mouth, pointy teeth and dark hair was the one who ultimately went home, leaving us with the (usually) nondescript sights and sounds of Syesha.

But the worst part of the night came before the elimination. As if Idol Gives Back's disgusting display of gratuitous Christian pandering weren't enough two weeks ago, tonight we were treated to a visit by none other than our contemptible president. Gee American Idol, what did the voters do to you to deserve such shabby treatment?

Furthermore, doesn't he have better things to do, like fix the economy, find a way to repair the effects of global warming, or, I don't know, fix the whole Iraq debacle? I'm sure the troops who put their lives on the line daily would be pleased as punch to know that their commander-in-chief has nothing better to do than address Americans on a cheesy, superfluous reality show.







You know what... (#1)
by Anonymous on Wed Apr 23, 2008 at 11:28:14 PM PDT
You have written nothing but negativity toward Carly and now gripe about her physical appearance. I don't know how you look like, but from reading what you have written, you are truly a horrible person with an ugly heart.

What's up with the negativity? (#2)
by Anonymous on Thu Apr 24, 2008 at 02:21:37 AM PDT
Resembles a creepy vampire? No, she resembles talent. Go nurture some of your own instead of harping upon the superficial details of a lovely person.

Carly Smithson (#3)
by Anonymous on Thu Apr 24, 2008 at 08:35:12 AM PDT
How pitiful you must be!  Most people who attack those they don't know are so miserable themselves, they seek to bring others down to make themselves feel better.  Shame on you!  Maybe you should work on improving yourself before you start pointing fingers and insulting others.

She actually looks like.. (#4)
by Anonymous on Thu Apr 24, 2008 at 09:24:49 AM PDT
Count Chocula. Even the picture on this story makes me want cereal.

P.S: She had a big contract, she sucked then and she hasn't gotten any better.


Yay! (#5)
by Anonymous on Fri Apr 25, 2008 at 11:25:16 AM PDT
Yay! Carly is gone--she was boring and not talented enough for Idol worship. Also, I watch American Idol so I can escape "W", not so that I have to watch him talk about the Idols and butcher more of my beloved language.

P.S. All you Carly worshippers (posts 1-3), jump on the Brooke wagon. Now she can sustain your desire for boring and off-key. Have fun with that!



ADVERTISEMENT