Asia'h Epperson: Bad song choice. This girl has a great throaty voice. I wish she'd do stuff that showed it off better.

Kady Malloy: B-O-R-I-N-G. As always.

Amanda Overmyer: I felt slightly better about Amanda tonight. I advocated for this girl big time in the beginning. I even dubbed her Hot Nurse. But her first few weeks on the small stage quickly changed that to Scary Nurse. Tonight I felt slightly vindicated. But having seen her up close I probably will never refer to her as "hot" again.

Carly Smithson: Boring. This girl is flat as a pancake. Yes, she can sing. But come on. Wake up! Have some personality, some soul - anything. Maybe that's why her first record deal didn't go so well.

Kristie Lee Cook: Also boring.

Ramiele Malubay: Cuteness will only get you so far, little Ramiele. Unfortunately, yours has worn off.

Brooke White: I've maintained my dislike for this blond-haired, blue-eyed goody two-shoes. But you've gotta give her props for knowing herself and choosing songs and changing them to fit her style. What she does just works. If only she didn't think she was so damn perfect. Grrr.

Syesha Mercado: I'll follow the judges' lead here: "Good."

The girls were a great disappointment. It would almost be easier to pick who should stay rather than who should go. Not to sound like a broken record, but my picks this week again are Kady Malloy (PLEASE!) and Kristie Lee Cook.