Quantcast willametteLive.com || Ask a Mexican

willamettelive.com - your source for news in the willamette valley
ADVERTISEMENT

   

Log-in | Signup (Free!)  |  Advertise  
Ask a Mexican
By Gustavo Arellano
from WillametteLive, Section Ask a Mexican
Posted on Wed Aug 25, 2010 at 09:44:49 AM PDT

Dear Mexican: I am a retired gringa living in Mazatlán, Sinaloa. Most of us foreigners here are liberal and sympathetic to the immigration problem, which the U.S. Congress refuses to address in a meaningful way. Unfortunately, I get lots of emails from acquaintances “apprising” me of the horrible situation in el Norte, and how all their tax dollars are being spent to educate and provide medical and Social Security benefits (Yes! They say that!) to these “criminals.” I used to laboriously write letters and show statistics and all that. IT DOESN'T DO ANY GOOD. Now, I ignore the messages but feel guilty about not trying to correct the bullshit. Can you give me a good short response to those emails? Something in Spanish telling them they are stupid would be nice, but some of them are actually friends! I will be forever grateful.

Gringa Near the Agua

Dear Gabacha Cerca de la Water: No, you should always respond with facts and stats, preferably disseminated by your humble Mexican scribe. Here’s a new one: did you know that fully 100 percent of supporters of Maricopa County Sheriff Joe Arpaio and Arizona governor Jan Brewer are fools? It’s the truest stat since someone determined that the sun rises and sets every day in the world’s non-polar regions. In reality, por favor never stop spreading the truth. The truth is like a Mexican: it can be ignored, spat upon, ridiculed, even deported, but it wins out. It perseveres. And the truth (and a Mexican) eventually multiplies to the point where it overwhelms anything before it. Name-calling and insults are muy fun, but pointless unless you come armed with those facts and stats—that has been this column’s mantra since Día One. Please do continue to provide stats to your so-called amigos; as for the good, short response to end each letter: ¡A LA CHINGADA CON ARPAYASO Y BREWJA!

I’m an old school veterano wondering why young 20- and 30-something Hispanic professionals are so afraid of the Chicano Movement. Is it because of those mean-looking Brown Berets? The women Brown Berets wore mini-skirts and go-go boots, but I admit even they looked angry. Or is it because of those Chicano and Chicana high school students who busted out of school to protest racism when they should have been going to their private SAT prep classes (oh wait: we couldn't afford those)? Or is it because some Movement leaders like Reies Tijerina spoke Spanish really fast? I know there are no more problems for young Raza with the educational system and foreign wars, but maybe ya'll should cut the poor old movimiento some slack.

En Pie de Lucha (With my Cane)

Dear In Struggle (Con mi Bastón): Same reason those same professionals criticize undocumented college students for staging protests outside the offices of Democratic Party bigwigs who don’t push enough for the DREAM Act, or why trade unions join forces with captains of industry today, alliances that would’ve wobbled the senses of their predecessors. It’s the same reason why the descendants of wops (like Arpayaso), micks, Polacks, and Krauts agitate for Know Nothing policies today. It’s the American way, profe: when people get their slice of the pastel, they forget the radicalism and activism that created the path that allows them to exist and be successful pendejos. But I do have to admit that in the case of hard-line Chicanos, many of our more-assimilated, less-radical hermanos y hermanas also don’t like y’all because of your nasty puritanical streak. Can’t tell you how many letters I get from otherwise-down people whom yaktivists ridicule because their skin is too light, their Spanish is too pocho, or because they can’t recite the poetry of Nezahuacoyotl upon request. Onward with la causa, but let’s leave ideological tests solely to politics and not to how mexicano one is, ¿sale?




How about ask an American (#1)
by Anonymous on Fri Sep 03, 2010 at 05:42:20 PM PDT
Why must you bash people for trying to make our borders safe? why bash hard working Americans when its obvious your country will not fix its self and depend on Americans to do it for you. Why not come here leagally and stop identity theft. Why not observe human rights and stop pissing on mine. As an American I have the right to freedoms illegals dont have. Understand this, as an American I will fight for this Country again. I know my founding Fathers would, how about yours?

Ask an American #2 (#2)
by Anonymous on Tue Sep 07, 2010 at 10:25:48 AM PDT
Here is a stat for you. Did you know that 100% of the supporters of this paper and the drivel published within are fools. The P.C. reverse racism found in the editorials from this "Mexican" makes me wonder why he would want to be here at all. If he is a Mexican instead of an American, then he should head on back and work on fixing Mexican problems. Does he know how they treat illegal immigrants in Mexico? I work hard for my money and pay taxes to the American Government not to subsidize Mexicans but to keep them where they belong, in Mexico, until they go through the legal process and decide in their hearts not to be Mexican anymore but to be Americans. Then I welcome them as fellow Americans with open arms.

Interesting (#3)
by Shawn Estes on Tue Sep 07, 2010 at 11:22:36 AM PDT
You both might be interested in reading two stories that we previously published on this column and Gustavo Arellano. Short version: He lives in America and pays taxes.

'Ask a Mexican' now in Salem Weekly

'Ask a Mexican' addresses racism, immigration, and culture clashes head-on.

I'd recommend replacing the word "Mexican" in that last comment with "Jewish" or "Irish" and look inward a bit.

Thanks for reading!

American (#4)
by Anonymous on Tue Sep 07, 2010 at 04:29:35 PM PDT
He lives in America but still thinks of himself as a Mexican. My wife is Jewish but does not let that define her. She is not Jewish American, she is an American. And if there are a whole bunch of Irish sneeking into the U.S. illegally, I would want them sent back to enter the proper way. We are a nation of laws, but every day turning into a nation of law breakers. And as for "The Mexican" he should be the one looking inward because it is people like him who promote, not address, racism, illegal immigration, and culture clashes.

Reply #4 (#5)
by Anonymous on Tue Sep 07, 2010 at 05:13:31 PM PDT
How do you compare a country to a religion? Is your wife from jewland? What's the problem with anyone being a Christian American or a Jewish American? Wow! It almost makes me think your wife is not assimilated if she makes it a point to separate the two, as if jewish was a nationality!

Jewish Mexican (#6)
by Anonymous on Wed Sep 08, 2010 at 01:15:19 PM PDT
Shawn Estes is the one who put Irish and Jewish in the same sentence, why don't you pick on him. Wow what an idiot, it sounds as if you do not realize that there is a Jewish culture and a religion. My wife was born of a Jewish mother from a family who immigrated LEGALLY from Isreal. She is not a practicing religious Jew and in fact is a Christian, but will always be a Jew because of her heritage and yet she would never describe herself as such. She would say she is an American period. Get a clue before you post idiotic statements!

Illegal Irish Immigrant (#7)
by Anonymous on Wed Sep 08, 2010 at 04:32:47 PM PDT
As the descendant of illegal Irish immigrants who hopped the border from Canada, I find this whole argument sort of ridiculous. My family has always paid taxes, and fought in this nation's wars, and I still identify myself as an Irish-American and enjoy a beer or ten on Saint Patrick's day. And interestingly, nobody ever hassles me, or my grandpa, for being "illegal". Of course, it helps an awful lot that we're white. Of course we're a nation of laws. But those laws often seem to be enforced more strictly when the perpetrators are brown.


 RELATED LINKS
> Also by Gustavo Arellano
 USER INFO

Login to post comments

Need an Account? Signup

Username:
Password:
 YOUR TURN
ADVERTISEMENT